Best Vegan Eyeliners 2020

Vegan eyeliners could be the underrated tool in your makeup kit. And let’s be honest here, we wouldn’t normally think that much how our eyeliner is made. We would simply look at the aspect on whether an eyeliner would fit her preferences or not. No more, no less. That’s the basic nature of it. On the other hand, it’s great to know that these cruelty-free options are widely available and we have, in our opinion the best Vegan eyeliners below. It is very convenient for vegans and vegetarians that carefully choose not just their plant-based consumer products, but also their sensitive choices for personal care.

Top 5 Best Vegan Eyeliners

Zuzu Luxe Liquid Eyeliner (Raven),0.1 oz,Precision liquid liner, fine calligraphy tip, quick-drying, water resistant. Natural, Paraben Free, Vegan, Gluten-free,Cruelty-free, Non GMO.

Not only is it water-resistant but also has gluten-free formula. Specifically, it is formulated with Jojoba oil that may serve as a key element for that smooth and easy application with the added benefits of keeping the skin around your eyes hydrated.

This vegan eyeliner features a fine calligraphy tip that could help you achieve that stroke you’ve been longing to perfect everytime you’re in front of the mirror. It offers wide range of shades. Raven being the most popular, storm, amethyst, black pearl, luxor, and nile just to name a few. You’ll just have to find the best shade that suits you. Most users of this vegan eyeliner came out to be merely satisfied with its overall results and how it can lasts an entire day, smudgeless, whatever physical activities you’re into. This could be a case to case basis but some are saying that the applicator will need some time to get used to. A quick overview, it kinda looks like a finely tipped paintbrush but is rigid. If you’re into liquid eyeliners and want to give it a try, it will not dissapoint. The big plus is, it’s all natural and cruelty-free of course.

100% PURE Long Last Liquid Eye Liner, Dark Chocolate, Long Lasting, Water Resistant, Smudge Proof, For Flawless Winged Eye Liner, Vegan Makeup - Brown Eyeliner (0.23 Fl Oz)

This vegan eyeliner from 100% Pure is known for its long-lasting effect. Well, obviously from what the name bears. This could be one of the most viable options for some with very sensitive skin.

This eyeliner was made in a base of gentle aloe and moisturizing vegetable glycerin. That crisp cat eye or retro winged liner look could be an effortless chore with this one due to its tapered brush tip. One of the brand’s greatest advantages though is instead of using coal tar and synthetic pigments, they only use superfine tea powder and cocoa within their eyeliner products, which adds up on why it can be more gentle and not irritating on your eyes. You should know that it’s a quick-drying eyeliner, advanced skills on drawing that winged eye look is a must. Otherwise, it could be a disaster. 

Mineral Fusion Coal Eye Pencil, 0.4 Oz

This vegan pencil eyeliner is known to be very delicate in the eyes. If you have sensitive skin, a great choice is what it is. Non-toxic and very easy to apply.

Formulated with chamomile, meadowfoam, and Vitamin E that is soother to the eyes after application. It’s organic and made only with natural minerals. With normal usage, lining could stay for an entire day, although some are saying that a retouch might be necessary depending on how you’re gonna spend your day. It covers five different shades to choose from – coal, azure, rough, touch, and volcanic.

Pacifica Beauty Natural Eye Pencil in Jet (Black), 0.1 ounce

This cruelty-free eyeliner from Pacifica is a popular choice among patrons of pencil eyeliners.

Application is as smooth as silk and is proven to stay longer in the eyes. It also has the characteristics and formulations commonly found in most all-natural and organic pencil types, making it delicate to the skin. The most satisfied users of Pacifica are into the richness of its color. It’s one thing to expect with this eyeliner, not unless if you’re into lighter shades because it’s only being offered in black, brown, and silver/grey. 

e.l.f. Cosmetics Cream Eyeliner, Create a Precise, Defined Look | Black 0.17 oz (1-Unit)

Quality vegan gel eyeliners are a hard-find, but with e.l.f Cosmetics, you’re getting the real deal.

This eyeliner’s long-wear formula provides smudge-proof, budge-proof, and water resistant quality. If you’ve been looking for the perfect gel eyeliner, this could be your one shot to long-term commitment. Needless to say, it’s PETA-certified, cruelty-free, and vegan. Gel eyeliners might be the underdog among the three but you’ll find peace with this one. Most users of this vegan eyeliner were long-time users of other big brands. And they couldn’t be any happier after having decided to shift with this one.

Which Would We Buy?

Other Vegan Eyeliners

Lavish Liner by Hairgenics Pronexa

Liquid eyeliner on a pen-type, oh how I love the convenience on application of this one. Technically, it dispenses the right amount of liquid liner in the liquid brush tip. Like a controlled environment waiting to be drawn. And of course, water resistant and smudge-proof, it could last all day. Ready for the big catch? Three words – eyelash growth serum. Yes my dear, this vegan eyeliner delivers natural eyelash growth as it is infused with eyelash growth serum and castor oil. Now tell me what’s cooler than that. In line with this, Pronexa is actually giving their customers a 2-month long period to see actual improvements with their lashes, and if you’re not satisfied, voila! Money-back guaranteed. If you came across the actual claims from users of Lavish Liner, you’d be suprised how happy there were with the consistent results.

INIKA Certified Organic Eye Pencil

The pricey option among our pencil types but definitely worth checking out. This all-natural eyeliner from INIKA contains no chemicals or other toxins, a trusty investment for women with sensitive skin and easily irritated eyes. It has been praised for its overall consistency and how it stays longer regardless of whatever occasion you’re in. Price might be the fallback for some but it is right for this one. Completely vegan and cruelty-free. Many users have found comfort with this eyeliner after trying out various brands that only cause them eye irritation.

These eyeliners are 100% vegan and cruelty-free. We have categorized this list to create an expansion of what your eyes would need. Liquid liners, for easy-handling and clean line creation. Pencils, work perfect into the lash line for a natural effect. Lastly gel, for that smudged smoky look.

Best Vegan Liquid Eyeliners

  • Zuzu Luxxe Liquid Eyeliner
  • 100% Pure Long Last Liquid Eyeliner
  • Lavish Liner by Hairgenics Pronexa

Best Vegan Pencil Eyeliners

  • Mineral Fusion Eye Pencil Coal
  • Pacifica Beauty Natural Eye Pencil
  • INIKA Certified Organic Eye Pencil

Best Vegan Gel Eyeliner

  • e.l.f Cosmetics Cream Eyeliner

Your Go-To Eye Grooming Tool

A woman’s daily routine wouldn’t be complete without accentuating her eyes with an eyeliner. It’s like the completion of a makeup quest to gain fierceness, confidence, even to summon their inner Hepburn-Monroe aura. Don’t you dare let a woman leave an unfinished business with their eyes. To them, it would almost feel like carrying an incomplete personality facing the world. I may have put it a bit metaphorical but a woman’s journey is always at pair with well-done stroked eyes.

Marching into today’s fashion, it’s a grind to find the perfect eyeliner. Admit it, your eyes have been in touch with a few hundred ones, or even more. I bet some of it was still sitting in your makeup drawer, waiting for its turn for your little sister or daughter to get discovered and tried on. Women wore it everyday. From top to bottom class, from teenagers to the working class. It’s been part of the makeup phenomenon for ages. The go-to eye grooming tool in a woman’s pouch.

What’s in Your Eyeliners?

Eyeliner can vary widely in terms of formulation. However, there are three particular elements that are commonly present with most – film formers, thickening agents, and pigments. Film formers are designed to lay down a thin layer on the skin, which makes the application easier, while the thickening agents make up the bulk of what eyeliner is made of by weight and volume. These include waxes, clays, and gums. Next stop, pigments. It basically makes up the coloring of the product. The most common include iron oxides for black and brown shades, titanium dioxide for lighter colors (including white), chromium oxide for green, and ultramarine for blue.

For those who are wondering if vegan eyeliners perform the same as the regular ones, the answer is a hundred percent yes. Hopefully, you may find these vegan eyeliner options worth-checking to. It’s great to know that there are cosmetic companies that actually care for ethical reasons. And they’re growing exponentially, hoping that someday, we’ll have enough eco-friendly options to choose from – maybe to the point that we won’t be needing the other side of the game anymore. At the end of the day, our choices often make us who we are and what we stand for. From your most-loved furniture at home up to the safest pocket-sized eye makeup tool. Now, time to nail that winged-eye stroke of yours.

Jenny Hutchings

Jenny Hutchings

I’m Jenny Hutchings and I share my healthy eating journey here! I hope you find the recipes and How-To guides useful, I look forward to hearing from you in the comments and on social media 🙂